Wednesday, July 19, 2023

Irving Female College, Mechanicsburg, Cumberland County

My bff Andrea and I are spending part of today attending the marker dedication for the Haines Shoe House in York County. So next week I'll be telling you about our adventures, and then the following week I'll be telling you about the marker and the house. That'll bring us into August, and those of you who subscribe to the monthly newsletter will be getting a big one because I may have sort of forgotten to send the one for July. (If you're not subscribed, there's plenty of time to sign up before the new one comes out - just use the handy little form on the right side of the blog. It's 100% free.)

Meanwhile, for today, I thought I'd head back to Cumberland County and take a look at a very interesting institute of higher learning. It's not a school anymore, but for a few decades it was one of the best places for a young woman to be educated, and at a time when only about 2% of women were attending college at all, that was an especially noteworthy feat.

The marker stands on East Main Street
near Filbert Street, in front of the former
college campus

As I mentioned when I wrote about the Cumberland Valley Railroad earlier this year, Mechanicsburg grew from a very small settlement into a significant town thanks to the growth of the railroad. By the 1850s, when the Pennsylvania Railroad purchased controlling interest in the Cumberland Valley Railroad, Mechanicsburg was evolving, and the area was becoming home to a number of wealthy businessmen and landowners. Quite a few of these came to the conclusion that having a college in the little town would grant it extra prestige and possibly boost tourism. One of these was a man named Solomon Gorgas, and he contributed a tract of his own land for the purpose in 1856.

The land, situated along what is now East Main Street in Mechanicsburg, was soon adorned with a beautiful building known as Irving Hall, and the school it housed was likewise dubbed Irving Female College. It was named for Washington Irving, the popular author who penned such famous stories as "The Legend of Sleepy Hollow." The author was even invited to serve on his namesake's board of trustees, and he remained a member from 1857 until his death two years later. Most of the students - there were usually fewer than one hundred at a time during the first decade - resided in Irving Hall, which served as a dormitory for forty students and also the classroom, parlor, library, and office of the college. Those students who could not live at Irving Hall resided elsewhere in Mechanicsburg.

Irving Hall's exterior remains to this day very similar to what it was at the time of its construction, minus the original bell steeple. It was designed to resemble an Italianate villa, standing three stories high and made of brick trimmed in wood. It features things like double-hung windows, French doors, large porches with carved wooden posts, and balconies. The first class graduated in 1859, with the ceremony featuring a speech by Rev. Conway Wing of nearby Carlisle. He referenced Psalm 114:12, and the school directors were inspired to adopt part of it as the official school motto: "That our daughters may be as corner stones polished after the similitude of a palace."

Irving College did well for its first several years, but from 1883 to 1886 it was forced to close due to lower enrollment and some less-than-stellar management. Fortunately, after it reopened, they gained E. E. Campbell as the school president. His leadership completely turned the school around, leading enrollment to rise (though at its height the school boasted only 132 students) and the school to expand. The increased enrollment led to the construction of a second building, Columbian Hall, which was built in 1893. This was also built in an Italianate style, but with Spanish influences; in addition to increasing the dormitory space, it provided the school with a large auditorium. Later, Irving Hall was expanded on its eastern wing to provide space for music classes, a gymnasium, and a bigger kitchen and a cafeteria. A president's mansion was also added to the campus in 1911, and the school grounds were professionally landscaped with more than 150 ornamental trees - some of which still grow there today. I took this picture of Irving Hall (left) and Columbian Hall during my visit.

As the school changed, the name sometimes did as well. From Irving Female College, it was altered to Irving College for Young Ladies, Irving College for Young Women, and finally - from 1895 until its demise - it was the Irving College and Music Conservatory. Whatever it was called, though, it was beloved by its students. Part institute of higher learning and part finishing school, Irving was always held to the highest academic standards, and was the first school in Pennsylvania to allow women to receive degrees in arts and sciences. The students began producing a literary magazine called The Sketch Book in 1895, and in 1901 they started publishing a yearbook. Proof of their affection appears in the 1907 yearbook, which contains the following comment:

There is no institution for the education of young women in Pennsylvania that surpasses Irving in convenience, comfort, and capacity of its buildings, or its beautiful and accessible location.

A lot of graduates went into teaching, inspired by their years at Irving, but a number of others went into more male-dominated fields. Ida Kast, a member of the class of 1892, became the first woman in Cumberland County to practice law. From the class of 1902 came Jane Deeter Rippin, later the national executive director of the Girl Scouts, who introduced the sale of Girl Scout cookies. (The cookies even have their own marker.)

But like so many good things, Irving came to its end. E. E. Campbell, whose leadership had saved the school, was also the unwitting cause of its downfall; he had purchased the school outright from the board of directors, and though he offered to sell it back to them when they regretted the decision, they could not (or would not) meet his asking price. In 1928 he tried to sell it to the Lutheran church, without success, and he died the following year. The trustees struggled to keep the school open, but the executors of the Campbell estate closed it, and though an effort was made by alumnae to raise the funds to reopen it, the school remained closed. Its three buildings were sold in 1937. 

The president's mansion was, for many years, part of the campus of Seidle Hospital, but was ultimately demolished in 1991 to make way for a hospital expansion. Irving and Columbian Halls were spared this fate, thankfully. After they were sold, both were converted into apartment buildings. Columbian Hall was the unfortunate victim of a fire in or about 1940, which caused significant damage to the third story and required a lot of renovation, but they have otherwise been altered as little as possible on the outside. They still stand as apartments today, and a number of features are still as they were when the college was open; the gatepost seen here, though no longer having a gate to support, was a gift from the class of 1909. Both buildings were added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1983.

As for the young women who studied on the beautiful Irving campus, they remained attached to their alma mater. Regular reunions were held by the assorted classes throughout the 20th century, though as the years passed the number of surviving alumnae dwindled. Ultimately, as a group, they donated their collection of Irving memorabilia to Mechanicsburg's public library. The collection includes photographs, postcards, graduation mortarboards, copies of the yearbook and literary magazine, and a series of oral histories from the alumnae themselves. The library has an entire section dedicated to the collection for those interested to see it. As the school's application for the National Register of Historic places puts it, "Irving provided Mechanicsburg with a source of culture, music, great literature and drama that the rural town would not have experienced otherwise." And they have never forgotten it.



Sources and Further Reading:

Cumberland Valley Visitors Bureau. "Celebrate Cumberland Valley Women During Women's History Month." Travel blog of VisitCumberlandValley.com, March 1, 2023.

Author unidentified. "Irving College." Gardner Digital Library of the Cumberland County Historical Society, circa 2016. Includes a photograph of the school's class of 1909 - all fourteen of them!

Reppert, Byron L. Images of America: Mechanicsburg. Arcadia Publishing, 2010.

Brosious, Patricia A. "Irving College." Pennsylvania Magazine, March-April 1994.



Except where indicated, all writing and photography on this blog is the intellectual property of Laura Klotz. This blog is written with permission of the Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission. I am not employed by the PHMC. All rights reserved.

No comments:

Post a Comment

I would love to hear from you!