Wednesday, March 1, 2023

Cumberland Valley Railroad, Mechanicsburg, Cumberland County

Many thanks to everyone who shared and commented on last week's post! I'm sure the good folks at the Liberty Bell Museum will be grateful that so many people have taken an interest in the museum's precarious situation, and I truly hope that we can make a difference.

Just a quick reminder that it's the first of the month, which means the newsletter has gone out with links to all of the February posts. To read it online, click here - and please do consider subscribing, it's free and sometimes there is exclusive content.

For today's post, I'm introducing the first new county of 2023. This past Saturday, Kevin and I made our way to Mechanicsburg for a meeting of our beloved Sherlock Holmes club, the White Rose Irregulars. After the meeting, we amused ourselves with running around the community collecting markers, and managed to get almost all of them. As a reward for his help, I treated him to some incredible homemade ice cream at Urban Churn Creamery. (I had the honey lemon lavender, and all I can say is that it's a good thing this place isn't closer to our house, because I'd go bankrupt.) This was the first of the seven markers we got that day, and we were a little chagrined that we were about twenty minutes too late to go inside the building in question.

The marker is in front of the former CVRR
passenger station at 2 West Strawberry Alley
I was actually never in Mechanicsburg until the White Roses began holding our quarterly meetings there. The streets are lined with many historic buildings and houses, some dating back as far as the borough's incorporation in 1828, and it's clear that the community is in touch with its roots. The location of today's quest object is a prime example of this.

The Cumberland Valley Railroad was not begun in Mechanicsburg, but the marker is here because the community is home to some of the best preserved buildings related to the CVRR - indeed, possibly the best preserved. The railroad was incorporated in 1831, and headquartered in Chambersburg, in Franklin County. Its original purpose was to provide both freight and passenger service between the Chambersburg area and Harrisburg; as need grew, it was extended, eventually reaching down through Maryland and into West Virginia. 

The line reached its completion in 1837, at which point Mechanicsburg was still rather small. It became more significant thanks to the railroad, which designated it as one of their water stations - a place where the rail workers could acquire water and firewood for the engines. The community grew as the railroad did, with trains bringing various goods into the area and making growth possible. 

The CVRR was a bit of a trailblazer, offering the very first passenger sleeping car on a train in the United States. The railroad became part of the most popular way to travel from Philadelphia to Pittsburgh; travelers would board the train from Philly to Chambersburg, during which they could make use of the sleeper car if so desired, and then from Chambersburg the rest of the trip was taken via stagecoach. This gave passengers a bit of an adventure until the 1850s, when the Pennsylvania Railroad was able to reach Pittsburgh. The more direct line was faster and rendered the stagecoach method obsolete.

The CVRR had something of a slow start, something that was made worse by a fire in 1844; a spark from one of their trains ignited the bridge to Harrisburg and nearly bankrupted the company. In 1859, controlling interest in the CVRR was acquired by the Pennsylvania Railroad, though they kept their name and existing staff. Two years later, the Civil War broke out, and the young railroad became much more important as a means of transporting Union soldiers and supplies for the Army of the Potomac. General Jubal Early and his Confederate troops marched into Chambersburg on July 30, 1864, and when the community failed to raise the exorbitant ransom he demanded, he and his men burned many of the buildings, which naturally had an impact on the CVRR and its employees. Despite this and any other setbacks, however, the CVRR's fortunes improved, and they came out of the war in a better financial position than they had been when it started.

After the war, the railroad experienced a boom, and Mechanicsburg's importance as a stop led them to build a passenger station and a home for the stationmaster. The house was actually finished first, in 1866, and the station was completed the following year. George Zacharias was the first stationmaster, and he and his family moved into the little house seen at left, which stands right beside the station. He had no excuses for being late to work. As the sign next to the back door indicates, the house was also the location of the community's telegraph office. A freight station was added to the complex in 1874, later replaced by a newer building in 1886. The railroad also added a number of parks along their line, trying to entice more people to travel for leisure; one of these was Williams Grove, near Mechanicsburg, which proved extremely popular and continued to operate until 2005. It's actually got a related marker of its own, so we'll be visiting it on a future quest.

With the new century, the CVRR and the Pennsylvania Railroad became more integrated. By 1919, the PRR shifted from merely owning controlling interest to owning the CVRR outright, and the name was changed to the Cumberland Valley Division of the Pennsylvania Railroad. Passenger service continued until 1959, and rail facilities in Chambersburg were closed in 1972. In the 1990s a plan was drafted to use the old Cumberland Valley Railroad Bridge as part of commuter rail service between Harrisburg and Carlisle, but the entire project was eventually scrapped.

Not all of the CVRR is relegated to memory, however. Mechanicsburg has lovingly preserved the passenger station and the stationmaster's house, which are on the National Register of Historic Places. They serve as a museum owned by the Mechanicsburg Museum Association, which provides guided tours of both. As I mentioned, we got there just a little too late to go inside, but we were able to walk around the station and peer through the windows, which is how I got this really neat picture of the model railroad they keep on display. (It gave me Mister Rogers' Neighborhood flashbacks, to be honest. This is not a bad thing.) The museum is open Wednesday through Saturday from noon to 3 p.m., and for special events as well. Admission for a regular visit is free; events such as their lecture series are free for association members and require a small fee from non-members. The MMA has also preserved the freight station, which serves as the museum's gift shop, and select pieces of their inventory are available for mail-order purchase through the official website.





Sources and Further Reading:




Westhaeffer, Paul J. History of the Cumberland Valley Railroad 1835-1919. National Railway Historical Society, Washington Chapter; Washington, D.C., 1979.


Except where indicated, all writing and photography on this blog is the intellectual property of Laura Klotz. This blog is written with permission of the Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission. I am not employed by the PHMC. All rights reserved.

No comments:

Post a Comment

I would love to hear from you!